An empty advent calendar is a harder problem than a full one. Twenty-four compartments is a lot of compartments, and the obvious answer puts a chocolate in every single one, which means that by the tenth of December nobody is excited and everybody has had enough chocolate. The containers are the easy part. The filling is where these things succeed or quietly fail.

At Circus of Wonders, we are in favour of a calendar that holds something other than confectionery, partly out of principle and partly out of self-interest. Here are 12 things to put in one, each with the rough age it actually suits.

1. Stickers and Temporary Tattoos (ages 2 to 6)

Sheets of small colourful stickers beside an open paper bag
Sheets of small colourful stickers beside an open paper bag

The ideal filler for the smallest children, because the thrill is instant and the thing is flat. A single sheet of stickers folded into a bag takes up no room, costs very little in bulk, and gets used within about four minutes of opening. Temporary tattoos work the same way and have the advantage of being visible all day.

2. One Building Block Figure at a Time (ages 4 to 10)

Small plastic building blocks and a figure arranged on a table
Small plastic building blocks and a figure arranged on a table

A single small plastic figure or a handful of bricks, one compartment at a time, building towards something by Christmas Eve. This is the filler with the best retention rate on the entire list, because it creates a reason to care about day nineteen. Buy a mixed bag rather than twenty-four separate things.

3. Hair Clips, Bobbles and Very Small Jewellery (ages 5 to 12)

Assorted hair clips, bobbles and a small beaded bracelet on a dish
Assorted hair clips, bobbles and a small beaded bracelet on a dish

Things that are lost constantly anyway, so a daily resupply is genuinely useful rather than merely festive. Clips, bobbles, elastics, a single bead bracelet. The practical advantage is that these are sold in packs of thirty for the price of one wrapped gift, which is how you fill half a calendar in one purchase.

4. A Single Pen or Pencil a Day (ages 4 and up)

Row of coloured and metallic pencils beside a small sharpener
Row of coloured and metallic pencils beside a small sharpener

One good pen, one metallic pencil, one tiny sharpener. By the end of the month there is a full set, which is a quietly clever trick: twenty-four individually unremarkable objects that add up to a real present. Works for teenagers too, if the pens are the kind they would not buy themselves.

5. Seeds, Bulbs and Something to Plant Them In (ages 6 and up)

Paper seed packets and a single bulb beside a small pot of soil
Paper seed packets and a single bulb beside a small pot of soil

A paper packet of seeds, a single bulb, a compressed soil disc. It is the only filler here that turns December into something that happens in March, and it suits children who are bored of objects. Forced bulbs planted in the first week will be doing something visible before the month is out.

6. Dice, Cards and Pocket-Sized Games (ages 6 and up)

Dice, playing cards and a small wooden puzzle on a dark surface
Dice, playing cards and a small wooden puzzle on a dark surface

A single die, a pack of playing cards split across several days, a tiny puzzle. These are the fillers that get used in the evening rather than abandoned by lunchtime. A deck of cards divided between four compartments is mildly infuriating and completely effective at making day four matter.

7. Coins, and the Argument That Comes With Them

Coins beside a glass jar partly filled with change
Coins beside a glass jar partly filled with change

Unfashionable and extremely popular with the recipient. A coin a day, ideally in a jar they can see filling up. It also does something no other filler manages, which is to turn the calendar into a small lesson about saving, assuming the jar survives until the twenty-fourth without being raided.

8. Hot Chocolate Sachets and Marshmallows (any age)

Mug of hot chocolate with marshmallows beside a small paper sachet
Mug of hot chocolate with marshmallows beside a small paper sachet

Technically adjacent to chocolate, admittedly, but it behaves differently: it is an event rather than a snack, it happens in the evening, and it involves sitting down. One sachet, a few marshmallows, occasionally a candy cane to stir it with. This is the filler that works in a calendar shared between several people.

9. Lip Balms, Scrunchies and Mini Skincare (ages 12 and up)

Small lip balms, a scrunchie and sachets of skincare on a dish
Small lip balms, a scrunchie and sachets of skincare on a dish

The teenage calendar is the hardest to fill and this is the category that reliably lands. Miniatures of things they already use, a scrunchie, a sheet mask, a decent lip balm. The trick is brands they recognise in sizes they would never pay for individually, which is exactly what the travel-size shelf exists for.

10. Notes That Promise Something Instead of Objects

Folded handwritten note slips in a small open box
Folded handwritten note slips in a small open box

A folded slip that says the park, a film, baking, staying up an hour late. No object at all, and consistently the compartment children remember in February. It also quietly solves the storage problem, since twenty-four promises take up less space in the house than twenty-four plastic things.

11. A Book in Instalments (ages 3 and up)

Open book with paper markers set between the pages
Open book with paper markers set between the pages

Either twenty-four very small books, which is expensive, or one book split into twenty-four marked chapters, which is not. The second version is better anyway, because it builds a reading habit that runs the whole length of December and finishes on Christmas Eve with the last chapter.

12. Socks and Other Things They Need Anyway

Rolled pairs of patterned socks in a small basket
Rolled pairs of patterned socks in a small basket

The unglamorous entry, included because it works. A pair of good socks, a new toothbrush, hair ties, gloves. Nobody is thrilled on the day, but it absorbs four or five compartments that would otherwise cost money and produce clutter, and everything in it gets used. Mix it in rather than building the whole calendar from it.


The best calendars we have seen mix three or four of these rather than committing to one, which also spreads the cost and stops the whole month feeling like a single repeated joke. Anything that is flat, cheap in bulk, or already needed is a good candidate. What goes in yours? Let us know in the comments!

Leave a Reply

Trending